Every once in a while we like to pit all the top FREE WEBSITE generator services together to see which one is the best. We don't just regurgitate what the commercials say, we actually test them and see which is the real value. Which, led us to create this free website here in the first place.
This years
DIY FREE Website Comparison Shoot-Out was no different. We put the advertising heavy-weights up against MySafeMedia.com and they flat out LOST EVERY CONTEST. So we posted a chart on the front page so everyone who wishes to know the truth could see.
Nicole, John and Abner all made free websites on the powerhouse services (the ones that would let them anyway) to learn the interfaces. Next they tried to make a website like this one using all available means from each provider. Being that this is primarily a textual site, we figured that the competition would be fair.
The first challenge was using the interfaces, which we did not evaluate as part of the comparison because there is too much opinion involved but props to MySafeMedia.com and VistaPrint, as the popular opinions were that they were the easiest.
Once we got done learning, the first test was to replicate this website using whatever methods we could and see how long it took. The goal was to do it in 5 mins! Now while that may sound ambitious, it only takes a few minutes to make a website if you have all the content to cut and paste.
So we began the comparo by visiting VistaPrint which is a huge powerhouse service with more than 13 million users. Our findings were that the service was fairly easy to use and the UI was solid. In direct comparison to MSM (MySafeMedia) there was some missing multimedia capability and NO social features.
Next we visited Wix, which is the current Flash based juggernaut. Wix lets you build beautiful and animated sites but there is not much actual functionality available beyond that. The UI was also complicated and slow. In direct comparison to MSM, Wix is better for those who have a love for flash but fairly useless for those looking to SEO a website or who want features like a BLOG or custom contact forms with data storage. Wix also produced painfully slow websites that frustrate visitors and search spiders.
After that, it was Microsoft's turn. We visited Intuit Websites and were able to make a site using the fairly typical UI. As with the others, this service lacks capability when compared with MSM but since it is powered by Microsoft the advertising does it's job and that is why the service is so very popular.
Finally, it was time to take WordPress for a spin. Our observations of the incredibly popular service was that it is NOT a tool to build a website at all, it is just a blogging tool. It does not compare to MSM but does have equal capability to the BLOG feature included with MSM websites. To be fair you must know that we actually used to host this site with a standalone WP install on our dedicated server and we did use many modules to achieve this same functionality as you get with MSM, but it took 11 modules and 11 installs to do that, and cost at the time $312 USD.
Replicating This site - times to completion are below:
MySafeMedia |
VistaPrint |
Intuit |
Wix |
Wordpress |
240 seconds |
FAIL |
FAIL |
EPIC FAIL |
FAIL |
Ok, after all 4 competitors failed, we decided that maybe we should stick to simple text and image based task instead, as none of the other services allowed true multimedia during the trial period or even if you paid. WordPress was the only service where you could come close due to the themes and widgets available, but you would still have to spend a lot of money to get all needed functionality and need to purchase hosting to install it.
Example#1:
WordPress FAIL - The *FREE online service cost
$60 per year to include Video and another
$30 to get rid of those annoying Advertisements on your Blog. Sorry WP, you have great templates and millions of users but, you're no longer a huge value. Times are changing it seems.
Example #2:
Wix EPIC FAIL -
This service produces an incredibly SLOW Flash site that is not search engine optimization friendly. Next!
Example #3:
Vistaprint -
Not FREE as it turns out.
Example #4:
Intuit Websites -
Not FREE and in fact is very expensive.
Next was test number two, which was to setup a Social Website that allowed members to join and comment, rate and follow conversations using automatic notifications. Again, WordPress was the only service where some modules could be found that allow at least partial functionality.
The rest were an EPIC FAIL.At this point we decided that the major advertised services were simply popular because of the advertising as NONE of them provided any value in comparison with MySafeMedia for most people. Sorry but they just don't.
So after using the entire day to see what those services DID allow you to do we posted the results in the following table:
Features | VistaPrint | Wordpress | Intuit | Wix | MySafeMedia |
Actual FREE Websites - No Ads |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Premium Features - $1.99 per month |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Upload Video, Music & Pictures |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Instant Site Template Swapping |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Members Can Join Your Site |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
5 Privacy Levels |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Email Blast Your Members |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Individual Member Profiles |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Social Networking Capability |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Members Can Follow Conversations |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Classifieds Section |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Automatic Notifications |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Public Announcements |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Comments & Ratings |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Automatic Slideshows |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Instant Video Chat |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
Custom Contact Forms |
No |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
We could go on but why bother? Those other sites are no where near the value of using MySafeMedia.com
|
So, after much time testing, we came up with the same end result as last year. Kids, it's another K.O. for MySafeMedia and another win for the people who have found out about the service.
The only complaint continues to be the lack of templates to choose from, but since the site is owned by an entrepreneur, its actually his call to offer more templates of widgets, so maybe they will in the future (hint, hint).
-CAFW Team
Create A FREE Website: MySafeMedia.com
"Create A FREE Website in minutes. Upload Pictures, Videos, Comment, Rate, SEO Tool, Memberships, Email Blasting, Privacy Levels, Video-Chat and much more. This is a great service!"
(
*****)
Review by A. Jenkins, February 2012